HSBC, Europe’s largest lender by assets, has long pinned its strategic future on Asia. Yet its latest earnings report illustrates the high-stakes gamble of that bet. In the first half of 2025, the bank reported a 26% plunge in pretax profit to $15.8 billion, falling short of analyst expectations and igniting concerns about the risks of concentrated exposure to China. The headline decline was driven by a fresh $2.1 billion impairment on HSBC’s long-held stake in Bank of Communications (BoCom)—one of China’s largest state-owned commercial banks—and compounded by $1.9 billion in credit losses, particularly linked to the struggling Hong Kong real estate sector.
While HSBC leadership tried to frame the impairments as largely non-cash and non-core, the numbers tell a broader story of geopolitical, regulatory, and market fragility in China—factors that are increasingly weighing on foreign banks with deep roots in the region.
China Exposure Turns Toxic
HSBC’s strategic alignment with Asia, particularly China, has always been central to its post-2008 identity. Roughly two-thirds of HSBC’s profit originates from Asia, and the bank has consistently expanded operations in the region, sold off Western assets, and increased its stake in Chinese ventures. But this aggressive tilt has also left it exposed to the structural vulnerabilities of China’s economy.
The most glaring example is its investment in BoCom. The $2.1 billion impairment this quarter follows an earlier $3 billion write-down in February 2024, amounting to over $5 billion in cumulative losses on the stake in less than 18 months. The impairments reflect:
- Reduced profit expectations from BoCom, as Chinese banks face declining margins and asset quality pressures.
- The impact of regulatory crackdowns by Beijing, which have squeezed the financial and property sectors.
- Rising concern that state-owned banks may prioritize political mandates over profitability, especially under the current economic stress.
The write-down does not affect cash flows, but it does signal a diminished valuation of one of HSBC’s cornerstone Chinese investments. CFO Georges Elhedery stressed that BoCom still pays annual dividends and that the impairment won’t erode the bank’s capital ratios. Still, the accounting adjustment raises uncomfortable questions: is HSBC’s China strategy a strength, or a liability?
Real Estate Troubles: A Slow-Burning Crisis
Adding to investor concerns was the near-doubling of expected credit losses (ECLs) to $1.9 billion—a sign that HSBC is bracing for more loan defaults, especially in real estate.
The Hong Kong property market, once among the world’s most resilient, is now under severe pressure:
- Home prices have fallen for consecutive quarters amid rising interest rates.
- Population growth has stagnated, weakening housing demand.
- Developers are finding it harder to refinance debt, raising default risks.
HSBC, as one of the dominant mortgage and corporate lenders in the region, is directly exposed. Beyond Hong Kong, the bank also holds structured finance deals and syndicated loans tied to mainland Chinese real estate, which continues to be rocked by developer defaults and incomplete housing projects.
Though HSBC maintains robust capital reserves, the cascading effects of property weakness could force further provisions in future quarters. These loan losses aren’t just theoretical—they threaten the profitability of the bank’s bread-and-butter lending operations in Asia.
Reassurances from Management—and Investor Skepticism
Despite the headline numbers, HSBC management was quick to offer a silver lining. Elhedery insisted that the impairments and credit losses were “accounting in nature” and not indicative of any immediate liquidity or operational stress. To support this position, the bank:
- Announced a $3 billion share buyback, signaling confidence in capital adequacy.
- Declared a 10-cent interim dividend, upholding its shareholder-friendly stance.
- Emphasized strong performance in net interest income, bolstered by high global rates.
- Highlighted resilient wealth management inflows, especially from affluent Asian clients.
Indeed, underlying operations held up better than the profit figures suggest. Excluding one-offs, HSBC’s core business benefited from global monetary tightening, and its wealth and commercial banking units in Asia remain profitable.
However, not all analysts are convinced. Some argue that the BoCom impairment is less about accounting nuance and more about deepening structural problems in China’s financial system. Others question whether HSBC’s 2026 return on tangible equity (RoTE) target of 15% is still realistic, given persistent drag from Asia and increasing global uncertainty.
Strategy Under Scrutiny: Concentrated Risk in Asia
HSBC’s predicament also revives an old debate: is the bank’s commitment to Asia a source of growth or vulnerability?
In early 2025, HSBC sold off its Canadian business for $10 billion, explicitly stating its aim to focus on core Asian markets. At the time, the move was seen as logical: Asia offered better margins, stronger demographics, and a growing middle class.
But that same concentration now appears risky:
- China’s regulatory unpredictability, as seen in crackdowns on tech and finance, unnerves investors.
- Rising U.S.–China tensions, and the growing likelihood of Western sanctions on Chinese firms, could disrupt cross-border banking.
- Domestic Chinese policy remains opaque, leaving foreign financial institutions in a difficult position.
In short, geopolitical risk is now financial risk, and HSBC must walk a tightrope between competing jurisdictions and ideologies. The bank is increasingly caught between Western regulatory expectations and Chinese political realities—a position that may become even more difficult to navigate in the coming years.
Bigger Picture: What HSBC’s Struggles Signal for Europe’s Global Banks
HSBC’s experience is not unique. Several European financial institutions—especially Standard Chartered, BNP Paribas, and Credit Agricole—also maintain significant Asian operations. The troubles now surfacing at HSBC may serve as a canary in the coal mine for the rest of the sector.
Key takeaways for peers and policymakers include:
- China is no longer a guaranteed growth engine. For years, Western banks expanded in Asia under the assumption that the region would outgrow regulatory and political concerns. That assumption is now being tested.
- Diversification remains essential. Overdependence on any single market—however promising—can backfire when economic tides turn.
- Non-cash impairments can reflect real-world risks. While accounting entries may not deplete cash, they often hint at eroding fundamentals.
- Real estate remains a latent risk. Property-led downturns in China or Hong Kong can impact not just loans, but also confidence, investment banking revenue, and wealth management flows.
What Comes Next?
For HSBC, the coming months will be a test of strategic resilience and leadership credibility. Analysts and investors will watch closely for:
- Further impairments or credit provisions in Q3 and Q4 2025.
- Updates on the BoCom investment and whether divestment is being considered.
- Clarity on regulatory risk management strategies, especially amid rising geopolitical frictions.
- Progress toward profitability targets, including RoTE and cost-to-income ratios.
There is also speculation about whether HSBC may recalibrate its Asia strategy, potentially scaling back exposure to certain segments or diversifying to other high-growth regions like Southeast Asia or India. Such a pivot, however, would require years—and may not be enough to offset current headwinds.
Balancing Growth and Risk in an Uncertain World
HSBC’s 26% decline in first-half 2025 profit is a clear warning: in today’s global economy, strategic bets carry strategic consequences. The bank’s $2.1 billion impairment on BoCom and $1.9 billion in credit losses reflect more than balance sheet volatility—they are tangible manifestations of a fragile Chinese economy, a weak Hong Kong property market, and a geopolitical landscape in flux.
While management insists the underlying business is sound—and backs that claim with dividends and buybacks—investors are rightly cautious. The narrative of Asia as a one-way street to growth is being rewritten, and banks like HSBC must adapt swiftly.
As the bank continues to navigate these complexities, one thing is clear: the line between opportunity and risk in global banking has never been thinner.
Disclosure:
The information above is provided for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice, trading advice, or a solicitation to buy or sell any financial instrument. All facts and figures should be independently verified; while we strive for accuracy, errors or omissions may occur. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Every investment carries risk, including the possible loss of principal. Always conduct your own research or consult a licensed financial professional before making any investment decision.